Dog Bells to Go Outside, Adjustable Dog Door Bell, Door Bells for Dogs, Quality Puppy Training Bell. Twisted Style, Lightgreen 2 pack...

Cute, light weight. Serves its purpose. Would recommend.

Cute & kind of worked - didnt stick to it as much as I shouldve

Our new rescue pup was having accidents inside. He wouldnt whine or scratch at the door like my previous dogs. I got these and taught him by simply shaking the bells every time he went outside. After just a few days he started to get it. Its been several weeks now and he is having little to no accidents inside. When he needs to go out he nudges the bells with his snout. It is definitely worth the money and time! These look nice and have held up well. They are adjustable, so you can make them a height that works for your pup and super easy to hang and implement.

Pros and Cons: CONS: 1. If you have a puppy in training, make sure they are only rewarded when they hit the bells to understand by doing so they need to go outside to potty. 2. If you do not make ringing the bells (even for an older already potty trained dog) as a reward system and allow your dog to use the hanging bells as a toy, the portion holding the bells can be easily chewed on, causing fray or chewing all the way through it. PROS: 1. Perfomance- Easy to use to train your dog by simply bringing them to the door, saying something like, "Do you need to go outside to potty?" with an excited tone, and then hold their paw up and manually guide them to hit the balls. Say, "No!" firmly if they, develop a play association with the balls other than to go outside to potty. This applies to both puppies in training and older dogs already potty trained. 2. Bells are of sound quality (loud enough to hear from another room and/or a loud TV volume setting), sturdy, won't bend if chewed on or accidentally closing your door on trapping the bell in the frame of the door. 3. Safety and performance of item is good. 4. Length cam be adjusted and will hang long enough for even those super extra mini dogs. CONS: 1. Do NOT allow this item to become a signal for anything BUT alerting you to their need to go outside to potty. *** This is especially important for those living in apartments and not simply being able to open the door to a secured backyard. If you live in an apartment and your dog consistently hits the bells just to go outside, as all dogs do, you'll find yourself going outside in order not to risk a potty accident inside. You will essentially reward your dog for developing a bad habit.*** *I'm giving this 4 stars because the CONS are user error and it would be incorrect to hold the seller responsible. I do not give 5 star ratings to any product, because nothing is perfect!

Our two pups love this and use it appropriately, all the time! We just jingled it once and they caught on right away. Our pups are adorable when using it. One uses her paw and the other uses his muzzle, typically. The chimes are pleasant to the ear which makes it nice. I'm really glad someone suggested this to me for our pups.